Showing posts with label National Book Award Finalist. Show all posts
Showing posts with label National Book Award Finalist. Show all posts

April 24, 2009

Luna

Title: Luna
Author: Julie Anne Peters
ISBN: 978-0-316-01127-3
Recommended Grade Level of Reader: 9th to 12th
Publisher: Little, Brown and Company
Media Type: Book
Copyright:  2004
Genre: Fiction

Reader's Annotation:  While Regan is battling to have her own life, Liam is struggling to become the woman he always wanted to be.  
 
Plot Summary:  Regan, the female protagonist, is a seemingly normal high school student.  Little does everyone know that she is dealing with a unique family life.  Her brother Liam has always felt like a girl.  Regan is the only one who knows Liam’s true feelings and identity.  Regan is the only one who knows Luna.  Luna, Liam’s female identity, has confided in Regan from an early age, snuck into her bedroom to play dress up, and almost revealed herself at one of Regan’s slumber parties.  Regan has spent so much of her life protecting her brother that she hardly has time for herself.  Luna captures the struggle of a girl trapped inside a boy’s body and the desire of another girl to have a life outside of her family.

Evaluation: (A)  Julie Ann Peters has created a captivating story of sibling connections, dysfunctional family relations, and quests for personal identity.  In particular, Luna’s character is unique, intriguing and convincing.  Although Luna’s story is told through Regan’s point-of-view, this method effectively delivers pertinent information the reader needs to know in order to understand and possibly empathize with Luna’s struggle.  Regan’s inner dialogue helps to highlight Luna’s journey from a young boy to a teen battling with gender identity issues.  Julie Ann Peters’ writing is so effective, descriptive, and suspenseful that on can’t help but to see the theatrical promise in this literary piece.  

Check This Out: Lesson Plans, Book Lists, and More...

Story of a Girl

Title: Story of a Girl
Author: Sara Zarr
ISBN: 978-0-316-01454-0
Recommended Grade Level of Reader:  9th and Up
Publisher: Little, Brown and Company
Media Type: Book
Copyright:  2007
Genre: Fiction










Reader's Annotation:  Some people make mistakes, but others make them with everyone looking. 

Plot Summary:  Deanna, the female protagonist, recounts an event from her past that earned her a bad reputation with her peers.  The story surrounds her dad catching her having sex at the tender age of thirteen.  He just so happened to find her during this escapade in the backseat of a boy’s car.  The boy, her brothers now ex-friend, bragged to his classmates and, as a result, Deanna got labeled as the school slut.  Story of a Girl begins on the last day of Deanna’s freshman year of high school.  Events unfold over the course of the summer concerning Deanna’s two best friends, Deanna’s brother, and a summer job that goes awry. 

Evaluation:  (A)  This story is based on the underlying theme of mistakes.  Specifically, one mistake can affect many facets of an individual’s life.  This is apparent in not only the plot concerning Deanna getting caught in the backseat, but also subplots pertaining to other characters such as Deanna’s brother.  Zarr does an excellent job at subtly incorporating this lesson into the novel without being too preachy.  Additionally, the character dialogue and Deanna’s inner thoughts are believable and could easily be attributed to a real life teenager. 

Check This Out: Lesson Plans, Book Lists, and More...